Top 20 'Boredom-Busting' Engagement Toys to buy for Your New Pet's Critical First 30 Days - Goh Ling Yong
Bringing a new pet home is a whirlwind of pure joy, fuzzy cuddles, and an overwhelming sense of love. You’ve prepped the house, bought the food, and picked out the perfect name. But after the initial excitement settles, a new reality sinks in: you are now the primary source of entertainment for this curious, energetic little being. Those first 30 days are not just about house-training and learning routines; they are a critical window for bonding and building your pet's confidence in their new world.
A bored pet is often a destructive pet. That shredded cushion or those scratched door frames? They're usually just symptoms of an under-stimulated mind looking for a job to do. This is where engagement toys come in. These aren't just simple chew things you toss on the floor; they are powerful tools designed to challenge your pet's brain, satisfy their natural instincts, and channel their energy into positive outlets. Investing in the right set of toys from day one can prevent problem behaviors before they start.
This guide is your ultimate shopping list for a successful first month. We’ve curated 20 boredom-busting toys that are perfect for helping your new puppy or kitten settle in, learn, and grow. From brain-teasing puzzles to soothing comfort items, these toys will help you build a strong, positive foundation for a lifetime of happiness together.
The Ultimate Toy Chest: 20 Must-Haves
Here are our top picks to keep your new furry family member happy, engaged, and out of trouble.
1. The Classic KONG
There's a reason the KONG is a staple in almost every pet owner's home. This durable, snowman-shaped rubber toy is incredibly versatile. Its hollow center is perfect for stuffing with treats, which encourages your pet to work for their food, providing crucial mental stimulation. It’s a fantastic tool for crate training, helping your pet build a positive association with their personal space.
For a new puppy, start with a puppy-specific KONG, which is made of a softer rubber for their developing teeth. Begin by making it easy: just drop a few loose, high-value treats inside so they fall out easily. As your pet gets the hang of it, you can increase the difficulty by wedging treats in more tightly or stuffing it with wet food, peanut butter (xylitol-free!), or plain yogurt and freezing it for a long-lasting challenge.
Pro-Tip: Buy at least two or three. This way, you can always have one stuffed and ready in the freezer while another is in use or in the dishwasher (yes, they're top-rack safe!).
2. The LickiMat or Lick Pad
Licking is a self-soothing behavior for both dogs and cats. A LickiMat, which is a flat mat with textured patterns, capitalizes on this instinct. By spreading a soft treat like pet-safe peanut butter, yogurt, or pâté-style wet food across its surface, you encourage your pet to lick, which can calm anxiety during stressful times like bath time, nail trims, or when you leave the house.
This simple tool is a lifesaver during the initial adjustment period. A new home can be overwhelming, and a few minutes with a LickiMat can provide a moment of focused calm. It also serves as an excellent slow-feeder, making a small treat last for ages and preventing your pet from gobbling it down too quickly.
3. The Snuffle Mat
A snuffle mat is a fabric mat with long fleece strips designed to mimic grass. You simply hide dry kibble or treats among the strips, and your pet uses their powerful sense of smell to forage for their food. This activity taps directly into their natural instincts, providing an incredible mental workout that can be just as tiring as a physical one.
This is a perfect activity for a rainy day or when your new puppy or kitten has the "zoomies" and needs a constructive way to burn off energy. It’s a low-impact activity, making it safe for all ages and breeds. It also helps build confidence in timid pets by allowing them to succeed at a natural, rewarding task.
4. Puzzle Boards & Sliders
Interactive puzzle toys, like those famously designed by Nina Ottosson, are the ultimate brain game for pets. These toys feature compartments, sliders, and levers that hide treats, requiring your pet to figure out how to access them. They come in various difficulty levels, so you can start with a Level 1 puzzle and work your way up as your pet becomes a seasoned pro.
These puzzles teach problem-solving skills and patience. For a new pet, they offer a structured way to engage their mind and build focus. Always supervise your pet during puzzle time to ensure they don't get frustrated and start chewing on the game itself. It's a fantastic bonding activity to do together.
5. A Treat-Dispensing Wobble Toy
Toys like the KONG Wobbler or the PetSafe Bob-A-Lot are a dynamic step up from stationary puzzles. You fill the toy with your pet's kibble or small treats, and they have to nudge, paw, and push it around to make the food fall out of the small opening. This turns mealtime into an active, engaging game.
This is an excellent way to slow down fast eaters, preventing digestive upset and bloat. It provides both mental and physical exercise as your pet chases the toy around the room. For a new pet, it’s a fun way to feed them one of their daily meals, ensuring they are tired and content afterward.
6. A Flirt Pole
Think of a flirt pole as a giant cat wand, but for dogs. It's a long pole with a bungee cord and a lure (like a fleece toy or animal skin) on the end. You drag the lure along the ground, encouraging your dog to chase it. This simple toy is a powerhouse for exercise and training.
A flirt pole can tire a high-energy puppy out in a very short amount of time, making it perfect for small yards or indoor play sessions. More importantly, it’s an incredible tool for teaching impulse control. You can practice commands like "wait," "get it," and "drop it" in a highly exciting context, which helps build a reliable foundation for obedience.
7. Wand & Feather Teasers
For our feline friends (and even some small puppies!), a wand toy is non-negotiable. These toys, with feathers, ribbons, or crinkly objects at the end, perfectly mimic the erratic movements of prey. Waving a wand toy for your new kitten engages their natural hunting instincts in a safe and appropriate way.
This interactive play is crucial for bonding and preventing "play aggression," where a kitten might start attacking your hands or feet. By directing their pounce-and-pounce energy onto the toy, you teach them what is and isn't okay to play with. Always end a play session by letting them "catch" the prey to avoid frustration, and store the wand safely out of reach when not in use.
8. Durable Chew Toys
Puppies explore the world with their mouths, and teething is a very real (and often painful) process. Providing appropriate chew toys is essential to save your shoes, furniture, and sanity. Brands like Nylabone and Benebone offer durable nylon chews in various shapes, sizes, and flavors that can stand up to powerful jaws.
For a new pup, choose a puppy-specific chew that is slightly softer. You can also find toys made of tough, durable rubber. The key is to offer a variety of textures to keep them interested. Having several appropriate chew options on hand means you can always redirect them if you find them gnawing on something they shouldn't.
9. Dental Health Toys
Why not have a toy that cleans their teeth while they play? Dental chew toys are designed with special textures, nubs, and ridges that help scrape away plaque and tartar as your pet chews. Many have grooves where you can add a bit of pet-safe toothpaste for extra cleaning power.
Starting this habit early in the first 30 days sets your pet up for a lifetime of better oral hygiene. It turns a necessary chore into a fun activity. Look for toys made from durable, pet-safe materials and always choose the appropriate size for your pet to prevent any choking hazards.
10. Silvervine or Catnip Chew Sticks
While we often think of chewing as a dog behavior, many cats also enjoy it! Silvervine sticks are a fantastic, natural option for felines. Silvervine is a plant that often elicits a more powerful euphoric response in cats than catnip. These sticks are great for dental health and provide a safe outlet for a cat's chewing instinct.
When introducing these to your new kitten or cat, let them sniff and explore it first. They may bat it around, rub on it, or start gnawing on the bark. It's a wonderful form of sensory enrichment that can help them relax and feel more at home in their new environment.
11. The Snuggle Puppy / Heartbeat Toy
Leaving their mother and littermates can be a stressful experience for a new puppy. A "Snuggle Puppy" is a plush toy designed to ease this transition. It contains a battery-powered "heartbeat" that mimics the feel of a littermate and a disposable heat pack for warmth, providing immense comfort and reducing separation anxiety, especially during the first few nights in the crate.
This isn't just a toy; it's a companion. Many new owners, including clients of pet experts like Goh Ling Yong, swear by this tool for helping a puppy settle into their crate quietly and sleep through the night. It can make the difference between a sleepless night and a peaceful one for everyone in the house.
12. A Soft Plush Toy with a Squeaker
Every pet needs a classic "cuddle buddy." A soft, plush toy can become a source of comfort, something for them to carry around the house or snuggle with in their bed. The addition of a squeaker taps into their prey drive, making it an exciting toy for gentle games of fetch or solo play.
When choosing a plush toy, look for durable stitching, especially if you have a puppy who loves to "disembowel" their toys. For the first 30 days, supervise their play with plushies to ensure they aren't swallowing any stuffing or the squeaker itself.
13. A Sturdy Tug Rope
Tug-of-war is a fantastic game for building your bond and teaching important commands. A good, sturdy rope made from cotton or fleece is a must-have. Contrary to old myths, playing tug does not make a dog aggressive; it's a healthy outlet for their natural instincts and a great way to engage in cooperative play.
Use your tug sessions as a training opportunity. Teach a solid "drop it" command by offering a high-value treat in exchange for the rope. Keep the sessions short and fun, and always let your pet "win" sometimes to keep their confidence up.
14. A Variety of Balls
You can never have too many balls! But don't just get a standard tennis ball (the felt can be abrasive to teeth). Stock up on a variety: a durable rubber ball that bounces erratically, a squeaky ball, a soft indoor ball, and even a "glow-in-the-dark" ball for evening play sessions.
For cats, small, lightweight crinkle balls or foam balls are perfect for batting around the house. Having different types keeps the game of fetch exciting and provides different sensory experiences for your new pet.
15. A Laser Pointer (Used Responsibly!)
A laser pointer can provide an intense cardio workout for cats and some dogs. They love chasing the elusive red dot. However, it's critical to use this toy responsibly. The chase never results in a satisfying "catch," which can lead to frustration and obsessive-compulsive behaviors.
To use it correctly, always end the laser session by switching to a physical toy, like a wand or a treat, that they can actually catch and "kill." This provides the closure they need. Never shine the laser directly in your pet's eyes.
16. Crinkle Toys
That rustling, crinkling sound is irresistible to many puppies and kittens. It mimics the sound of small critters moving through grass or leaves, triggering their curiosity and prey drive. Crinkle toys come in all shapes and sizes, from flat, stuffing-free animals to small, lightweight balls for cats.
These are great for sensory stimulation. The unique sound and texture provide a different kind of engagement than a standard squeaky toy. They are often lightweight and easy for a small pet to carry around.
17. Automated/Electronic Toys
For times when you're busy but your pet is not, an automated toy can be a great substitute. This could be an automatic ball launcher for a fetch-obsessed dog or a self-rotating laser or feather toy for a cat. These can help burn off excess energy when you can't be actively playing.
It's important to remember that these are not a replacement for one-on-one interaction. They are best used for short periods to supplement your playtime together. Always supervise your pet initially to ensure they are comfortable with the toy's movements and sounds.
18. Slow Feeder Bowls
While technically a bowl and not a toy, a slow feeder turns every meal into a brain-teasing puzzle. These bowls have mazes and obstacles molded into them, forcing your pet to slow down and work to get their kibble. This not only prevents dangerous bloat but also provides daily mental enrichment.
Using a slow feeder is one of the easiest ways to incorporate "boredom-busting" into your pet's daily routine. It makes mealtime last longer and provides a satisfying challenge, which is perfect for a new pet who is still learning their daily schedule.
19. Training Clicker & Treat Pouch
Okay, not a toy, but arguably the most important engagement tool for the first 30 days. Clicker training is a powerful and positive way to teach your new pet commands and behaviors. The "click" marks the exact moment your pet does something right, followed by a reward. A treat pouch ensures you always have rewards ready.
Engaging your pet in short, fun training sessions throughout the day is one of the best ways to build their confidence, strengthen your bond, and stimulate their mind. Teaching simple cues like "sit," "touch," and "watch me" gives your new pet a "job" and helps them understand how to succeed in their new home.
20. A DIY Foraging Box
You don't need to spend a fortune to keep your pet engaged. A simple cardboard box can become the best toy ever. Take a box, fill it with pet-safe packing paper, toilet paper rolls, or even some of their toys, and sprinkle a handful of their kibble or treats inside.
This DIY foraging box encourages your pet to dig, sniff, and explore to find the rewards. It's a cheap, effective, and endlessly customizable enrichment activity. Just be sure to remove any tape or staples from the box, and always supervise to make sure they're not eating the cardboard.
A Happy Pet is a Busy Pet
Those first 30 days with your new pet are a precious, formative time. By providing a rich environment full of positive and engaging outlets for their energy, you are not just preventing boredom—you are building a confident, well-adjusted companion for life. Rotate these toys to keep things fresh and exciting, and pay attention to what your pet enjoys most.
Your role as their primary playmate is one of the most rewarding parts of being a pet owner. A few minutes of focused, interactive play each day will do more for your bond than anything else.
What are your must-have toys for a new puppy or kitten? Did we miss any of your favorites? Share your top picks in the comments below to help out other new pet parents!
About the Author
Goh Ling Yong is a content creator and digital strategist sharing insights across various topics. Connect and follow for more content:
Stay updated with the latest posts and insights by following on your favorite platform!