Top 5 'Privacy-First' Analytics Tools to start for your Shopify Store in 2025
Hey everyone, it's Goh Ling Yong. If you're running a Shopify store, you’ve probably spent countless hours staring at your analytics dashboard, trying to decode customer behavior. For years, the default answer has been Google Analytics. But the ground is shifting beneath our feet. The digital world is heading towards a "cookieless" future, and privacy regulations like GDPR and CCPA are no longer just suggestions—they're the law.
This isn't just a technical problem; it's a trust problem. Today's online shoppers are more savvy and privacy-conscious than ever. They're tired of invasive tracking, and they're actively using tools to block it. This means that traditional, cookie-based analytics are becoming less accurate and, in some cases, a legal liability. Relying on them is like trying to navigate a new city with an old, torn map.
But what if I told you this change is actually a massive opportunity? An opportunity to build deeper trust with your customers, simplify your data, and get more accurate insights into what truly matters. The solution lies in a new breed of tools: privacy-first analytics. These platforms are designed from the ground up to respect user privacy while still giving you the actionable data you need to grow your Shopify store. Let's dive into the top five you should consider for 2025.
1. Plausible Analytics
If you're looking for a simple, lightweight, and powerful alternative to Google Analytics, Plausible should be at the top of your list. It's an open-source platform that strips away the complexity and focuses on delivering the essential metrics you need in a clean, one-page dashboard. The best part? It does this without using cookies or collecting any personal data.
Plausible's tracking script is tiny—less than 1KB. For a Shopify store, site speed is everything. A slow-loading site can kill your conversion rates. By ditching the heavy, bloated scripts of traditional analytics, Plausible ensures your store remains fast and responsive, improving both user experience and SEO. It's fully compliant with GDPR, CCPA, and PECR out of the box, so you don't need annoying cookie banners when you're only using Plausible for your analytics.
How to use it for your Shopify store:
Imagine you run a store selling artisanal coffee beans. You can use Plausible to track which blog posts—like "The Ultimate Guide to French Press Coffee"—are driving the most traffic to your product pages. You can set up custom event goals to track key actions like "Add to Cart," "Initiate Checkout," or even clicks on your "Subscribe & Save" button. This gives you clear, actionable data on what's working without overwhelming you with dozens of vanity metrics. The focus here is on clarity and speed, helping you make smarter decisions, faster.
2. Fathom Analytics
Fathom is another fantastic player in the privacy-first analytics space, known for its beautiful design and unwavering commitment to privacy. Like Plausible, Fathom is cookieless and GDPR-compliant by default. It was built by and for independent creators and entrepreneurs, so it understands the need for straightforward, reliable data without the corporate-level complexity.
What sets Fathom apart is its elegant, single-page dashboard that shows you everything you need at a glance: current visitors, top pages, top referrers, and key events. There are no complicated menus or layers of reports to dig through. It even includes a unique uptime monitoring feature, which will notify you if your Shopify store ever goes down—a small but incredibly valuable bonus. Fathom's entire business model is built around selling software, not data, so you can be confident your customers' information is never being harvested or sold.
How to use it for your Shopify store:
Let's say you run a high-end fashion boutique on Shopify and just collaborated with a major Instagram influencer. With Fathom, you can see the real-time spike in traffic from that influencer's link in a single, clear chart. You can easily track how many of those visitors landed on your new collection page and see the overall conversion rate for your campaign goals. This simplicity allows you to quickly assess the ROI of your marketing efforts without needing a data science degree.
3. Matomo
For those who feel they need the power and depth of Google Analytics but want to take back control of their data, Matomo is the undisputed champion. It's an incredibly robust, open-source platform that can be used in two ways: Matomo Cloud (for easy setup) or Matomo On-Premise, where you host the software on your own servers for 100% data ownership.
Matomo is packed with advanced features that go beyond simple traffic stats. It offers heatmaps to see where users are clicking, session recordings to watch anonymized user journeys, A/B testing capabilities, and detailed conversion funnel analysis. Because you control the data, you can ensure it's handled in a way that fully complies with privacy laws. Matomo gives you the best of both worlds: enterprise-grade features with a privacy-centric foundation. It's a topic I, Goh Ling Yong, have been tracking closely, as more large-scale e-commerce businesses are looking for this exact combination of power and control.
How to use it for your Shopify store:
If you're a larger Shopify Plus merchant, Matomo is a game-changer. You could use its funnel analysis feature to pinpoint exactly where customers are dropping off in your multi-step checkout process. Are they leaving when you ask for shipping info? Or at the payment step? The session recording feature could then show you an anonymized replay of a user struggling with a specific form field, giving you a clear signal to improve your UX. This level of insight, all while maintaining full data ownership, is something other tools on this list can't offer.
4. Simple Analytics
The name says it all. Simple Analytics is for the minimalist who believes that less is more. If you find even Plausible or Fathom to be too much, this tool will feel like a breath of fresh air. It's designed to give you just the essentials: page views, referrers, top pages, and device information. That’s it. The entire focus is on privacy and simplicity.
Simple Analytics is proudly cookieless and collects zero personal information. Its dashboard is incredibly clean and intuitive. One of its standout features is its ability to bypass most ad-blockers (ethically, by routing through your own domain) which can give you a more accurate picture of your true traffic numbers. It also has a neat feature where you can see a live feed of tweets that mention your website, integrating social buzz directly into your analytics.
How to use it for your Shopify store:
Picture yourself as the owner of a niche Shopify store selling handmade ceramics. You don't need complex funnel analysis or heatmaps. You just want to know: Are people finding my store? Where are they coming from? And which products are they looking at most? Simple Analytics answers these questions beautifully. You can easily see if that feature on a popular craft blog sent you a wave of new visitors and which of your new vase designs is getting the most attention, all from a dashboard you can understand in 30 seconds.
5. Pirsch Analytics
Pirsch is a newer, developer-friendly analytics tool that prioritizes performance and flexibility. Built in Germany, it has a strong European focus on privacy baked into its DNA. Like the others, it's a cookieless, GDPR-compliant solution, but its main selling point is its extreme speed and minimal footprint. The tracking script is tiny and won't add any noticeable load time to your Shopify store.
Pirsch offers a clean, real-time dashboard and is designed for easy integration. You can track simple page views or set up complex custom events using its straightforward API. It's also open-source and can be self-hosted, giving you another option for full data control similar to Matomo, but in a much more lightweight package. It's the perfect choice for store owners who are obsessed with performance and want a no-nonsense, technically sound analytics platform.
How to use it for your Shopify store:
For a Shopify store selling tech gadgets or high-performance gear, every millisecond of page load time counts. You could use Pirsch to track key conversion events, like newsletter sign-ups or "Add to Wishlist" clicks, without adding any performance overhead. Its real-time dashboard lets you see the immediate impact of a flash sale or a product launch as it happens. For the technically inclined, you can even pipe this data into other internal dashboards or systems using its API, giving you ultimate flexibility.
Your Next Step in a Privacy-First World
Choosing to move away from traditional analytics isn't just about compliance; it's a strategic business decision. By adopting a privacy-first tool, you're sending a clear message to your customers: "We respect you and your data." This builds trust, which is the ultimate currency in e-commerce. You also get the added benefits of faster site speed and cleaner, more focused data that can lead to better decisions.
The great thing is, you don't have to lose out on valuable insights. As you can see from the tools above—from the powerful Matomo to the minimalist Simple Analytics—there is a perfect privacy-first solution for every type of Shopify store. My goal is to help you navigate this changing landscape with confidence. The future of e-commerce is one where privacy and profitability go hand in hand.
So, which tool are you leaning towards? Do you have any experience with privacy-first analytics on your Shopify store? Share your thoughts and questions in the comments below—I'd love to hear from you
About the Author
Goh Ling Yong is a content creator and digital strategist sharing insights across various topics. Connect and follow for more content:
Stay updated with the latest posts and insights by following on your favorite platform!