Top 6 'Secret-Menu' Supper Club Dishes to cook for adventurous foodies in 2025 - Goh Ling Yong
The supper club scene is electric. It’s where culinary magic happens, away from the predictable menus and formal fuss of traditional restaurants. It’s about community, intimacy, and the thrill of tasting something new, something special, something you can’t get anywhere else. For the host, it’s a stage to share your passion. For the guest, it’s a ticket to an exclusive culinary adventure.
As we look towards 2025, the definition of a standout supper club experience is evolving. It's no longer just about delicious food; it's about the story, the technique, and the element of surprise. The most memorable evenings are built around dishes that make your guests lean in and ask, "What is this? It's incredible!" This is the power of the 'secret menu'—dishes that are ambitious, unexpected, and deeply rewarding to both cook and eat.
So, how do you capture that magic in your own kitchen? How do you craft a menu that positions you as a culinary insider for your most adventurous foodie friends? Forget the safe bets. We’re diving deep into the concepts, techniques, and flavour combinations that will define the most exciting home dining experiences of 2025. This is your guide to the ultimate supper club brag list.
1. Koji-Aged Duck with Fermented Plum Sauce
The Dish: Imagine a duck breast with skin so crisp it shatters like glass, revealing meat that is profoundly tender, savoury, and packed with an umami depth you've never experienced before. This isn't just any duck; it's been transformed by Koji, the magical mould responsible for miso, soy sauce, and sake. The ageing process with Koji tenderises the meat on a molecular level while developing complex, savoury, and slightly funky notes. Paired with a sharp, tangy, house-fermented plum sauce, it’s a masterclass in balance.
Why it’s a Secret-Menu Star: This dish screams dedication. Koji-ageing is a technique used by high-end chefs that is surprisingly accessible to the dedicated home cook. It shows you’re not just following a recipe; you’re engaging in a culinary process. It takes planning and patience, making the final result feel earned and exclusive. For your guests, it’s an introduction to a powerful ingredient that fundamentally changes the nature of the protein, creating a flavour that is both new and deeply satisfying.
Pro-Tips:
- Sourcing Koji: You can buy dried rice Koji (Koji-kin) online or from Japanese specialty stores. To use it, simply pulse it into a powder, mix it with a bit of salt and water to form a paste, and coat the duck breast.
- The Ageing Process: Let the Koji-coated duck age uncovered in your refrigerator on a wire rack for 2-3 days. The Koji will work its magic, and the skin will become perfectly dry, which is the key to an impossibly crispy sear.
- Quick Fermented Plum Sauce: You don’t need months to get a great result. Finely chop plums, mix with 2% of their weight in salt, and add a star anise and a slice of ginger. Let it sit in a sealed jar at room temperature for 4-5 days, burping it daily. The result is a vibrant, funky, and salty-sweet condiment that cuts through the richness of the duck beautifully.
2. Monkfish "Osso Buco" with Saffron and Sea Fennel
The Dish: This is where you playfully subvert expectations. Osso Buco, the classic Italian braised veal shank, is reimagined with a hero from the sea. Monkfish, often called the "poor man's lobster," has a firm, meaty texture that holds up perfectly to slow cooking. We treat thick-cut medallions from the tail like a traditional shank, searing them golden before braising them in a fragrant, saffron-infused white wine and tomato broth. The dish is finished with a Gremolata made not with parsley, but with foraged sea fennel for a briny, aromatic kick.
Why it’s a Secret-Menu Star: It’s a brilliant bait-and-switch that showcases an under-appreciated fish in a completely novel way. Most people have never had monkfish, and even fewer have had it prepared like this. It demonstrates creativity and a deep understanding of ingredients—knowing that monkfish’s texture can mimic meat. The saffron adds a touch of luxury, while the sea fennel Gremolata is a unique, coastal detail that will have your foodie friends raving.
Pro-Tips:
- The Cut: Ask your fishmonger for thick, bone-in medallions from the tail of a large monkfish if possible. The bone will add flavour to the braising liquid, just like in a traditional Osso Buco. If not, thick boneless steaks work wonderfully too.
- Build the Flavour Base: The key to a great braise is the soffritto. Sauté finely chopped onion, carrot, and celery until soft and sweet before adding garlic, wine, and tomatoes. Don’t rush this step.
- Sea Fennel Sourcing: This wild, edible plant grows on coastlines and has a distinct flavour—like a mix of parsley, carrot, and salty sea air. If you can't find it, you can substitute with a mix of chopped fennel fronds and celery leaves, adding a pinch of celery salt to mimic its flavour. Serve this dish over a creamy polenta or pearl couscous to soak up every last drop of the golden sauce.
3. Smoked Lion's Mane "Scallops" on Black Venus Rice Risotto
The Dish: Here is your plant-based showstopper, a dish so compelling it will make even the most devoted carnivore swoon. Lion's Mane mushrooms are a culinary marvel; when torn and seared, their texture is uncannily similar to that of a diver scallop. Before searing, we give the mushrooms a gentle cold-smoke to impart a deep, woodsy flavour. These "scallops" are served atop a stunning risotto made from Black Venus rice—a whole-grain Italian rice that cooks up to a deep, dramatic purple-black and has a wonderfully nutty bite.
Why it’s a Secret-Menu Star: This dish single-handedly elevates vegetarian cooking from an afterthought to the main event. It’s visually spectacular, texturally surprising, and deeply complex in flavour. It showcases a trendy ingredient (Lion's Mane) and a sophisticated technique (cold-smoking) that adds a layer of intrigue. It’s proof that a meal doesn’t need meat to be indulgent, creative, and completely unforgettable.
Pro-Tips:
- The "Scallop" Sear: To get a perfect sear on your mushrooms, use a very hot cast-iron skillet with a neutral oil. Don't crowd the pan, and press them down gently with a spatula. Let them cook without moving until a deep golden-brown crust forms. This is where the magic happens.
- Smoking at Home: You don't need a giant smoker. A handheld smoking gun is an affordable and effective tool for the home kitchen. Just place the torn mushrooms in a bowl, cover it with plastic wrap, and pipe the smoke in, letting it infuse for 10-15 minutes.
- Creamy Vegan Risotto: To make the black rice risotto luxuriously creamy without dairy, finish it with a spoonful of cashew cream (soaked cashews blended with water) and a generous sprinkle of nutritional yeast for a cheesy, savoury flavour.
4. Deconstructed Birria Ramen
The Dish: Two titans of comfort food—Mexican Birria and Japanese Ramen—collide in this spectacular fusion. This isn't just Birria broth with noodles thrown in. It’s a thoughtful deconstruction. Guests are presented with a bowl of perfectly cooked, springy ramen noodles topped with tender, shredded Birria lamb (or beef), crisp radishes, pickled red onions, and cilantro. Alongside it, a small teapot holds the soul of the dish: the rich, complex, brick-red Birria consommé, glistening with chili oil. The experience is interactive—guests pour the steaming broth over their noodles or use it as a dipping sauce, à la tsukemen.
Why it’s a Secret-Menu Star: This is what modern, adventurous eating is all about. It’s a "third-culture" dish that respectfully borrows from two beloved cuisines to create something entirely new and exciting. It’s a dish I, Goh Ling Yong, have spent countless hours perfecting, balancing the smoky depth of the chiles with the clean fundamentals of a good ramen. Serving it deconstructed transforms the meal from a simple bowl of soup into an engaging, multi-sensory experience. It’s fun, it’s messy, and it’s unbelievably delicious.
Pro-Tips:
- The Chile Blend is Key: Don't just use one type of chile. A combination of mild, fruity guajillo, smoky ancho, and a touch of fiery chile de árbol will create a consommé with incredible depth and complexity. Remember to toast them first to wake up their flavours.
- Noodle Matters: Don't skimp on the noodles. Source high-quality fresh or frozen ramen noodles from an Asian market. Their chewy, alkaline texture is essential and cannot be replicated by instant noodles.
- The Finishing Touches: The garnishes aren't just for looks; they are crucial for balance. The sharp pickled onions cut through the richness of the meat, the cilantro adds freshness, and a squeeze of lime at the end brightens everything up.
5. Celeriac "Bolognese" with Hand-Cut Pappardelle and Cured Egg Yolk
The Dish: Prepare to blow your guests' minds with a "meat" sauce that contains no meat. This is a culinary sleight-of-hand. The humble celeriac (celery root) is slow-roasted until sweet and nutty, then finely minced to perfectly mimic the texture of ground meat. This forms the base of a rich, savoury sauce built with classic Bolognese flavours: a soffritto, good San Marzano tomatoes, a splash of red wine, and a secret umami weapon like mushroom powder or a touch of white miso. Served with rustic, hand-cut pappardelle, the dish is finished not with Parmesan, but with a shower of grated, salt-cured egg yolk.
Why it’s a Secret-Menu Star: It's an illusion. It delivers all the comforting, soul-warming satisfaction of a classic Bolognese but in a completely unexpected, plant-based format. This dish requires technique and an understanding of how to build flavour without relying on meat. The cured egg yolk is the final flourish—a gourmet touch that adds a salty, fatty richness that perfectly replaces cheese and will leave your guests utterly mystified and impressed.
Pro-Tips:
- Cure Your Own Yolks: This is incredibly easy and impressive. Make a bed of a 50/50 salt and sugar mixture in a small container. Create small wells, gently drop in the egg yolks, and cover them completely with more of the salt-sugar mix. Refrigerate for 4-7 days. The yolks will become firm, translucent, and ready to be rinsed, dried, and grated with a microplane.
- Hand-Cut Pasta: Making your own pasta is a therapeutic process that elevates any meal. Even a simple egg-and-flour dough, rolled out thin and cut into wide pappardelle ribbons, will have a texture and flavour that store-bought pasta can't match.
- Umami Bombs: To deepen the "meaty" flavour of the celeriac, add finely chopped porcini mushrooms, a tablespoon of dark soy sauce, or a dab of tomato paste that you’ve caramelized in the pan before adding liquids.
6. Hot River Stone "Ishiyaki" with A5 Wagyu and Yuzu Kosho Butter
The Dish: This is less of a dish and more of a dining event. Ishiyaki, or stone cooking, is pure culinary theatre. Smooth, dark river stones are heated in the oven to a searing temperature and presented at the table. Your guests are given plates of paper-thin slices of exquisite A5 Wagyu beef, a pot of melted Yuzu Kosho butter, and various dipping sauces. They then cook the beef themselves, slice by slice, on the sizzling hot stone. The sound, the aroma, and the interactive nature make for an unforgettable centerpiece.
Why it’s a Secret-Menu Star: It’s the ultimate flex for a supper club host. It’s luxurious, interactive, and inherently communal. Sourcing A5 Wagyu and dedicated culinary stones shows you’re serious about providing a top-tier experience. The focus is entirely on the quality of a single, perfect ingredient. The accompanying Yuzu Kosho butter—a fiery, citrusy, and fragrant Japanese condiment mixed with high-quality butter—is a modern touch that cuts through the intense richness of the beef. This isn’t just dinner; it’s a core memory in the making.
Pro-Tips:
- Safety and Sourcing: Use only specific culinary-grade cooking stones (lava stones or granite are common) that can withstand high temperatures without cracking. Heat them in a 250°C (500°F) oven for at least an hour. Handle them with extreme care and place them on wooden trivets or heat-proof plates at the table.
- Sourcing Wagyu: Look for a reputable online supplier or a high-end butcher. For Ishiyaki, you want very thin slices (like for shabu-shabu) from a cut like ribeye or sirloin. A little goes a long way with A5 Wagyu, as it’s incredibly rich.
- The Butter and Dips: Simply melt unsalted butter and whisk in a teaspoon of Yuzu Kosho paste. Beyond that, offer a simple, high-quality sea salt (like Maldon) and perhaps a light ponzu sauce for dipping. You don't want to overshadow the magnificent flavour of the beef itself.
Your Next Culinary Adventure Awaits
Hosting a supper club for adventurous foodies in 2025 is about pushing boundaries and creating an experience, not just a meal. These six "secret-menu" concepts are your starting point. They are designed to be adapted, experimented with, and made your own. They challenge you as a cook and delight your guests with flavours, textures, and ideas they’ve never encountered before.
The real secret ingredient, after all, is your own passion and creativity. Take these ideas, run with them, and build an evening of culinary discovery that your friends will be talking about for years to come.
So, which dish will be making an appearance at your next dinner party? Are you ready to dive into Koji-ageing, or is the theatre of hot stone cooking calling your name?
Share your plans and your own secret-menu ideas in the comments below. I can't wait to see what you create!
About the Author
Goh Ling Yong is a content creator and digital strategist sharing insights across various topics. Connect and follow for more content:
Stay updated with the latest posts and insights by following on your favorite platform!