Top 8 'Debate-Sparking' Book Club Picks to start at home for your next couples' night in. - Goh Ling Yong
Let's be honest, how many of your recent "date nights in" have devolved into the endless, soul-sucking scroll through Netflix? You know the one. You spend 45 minutes debating what to watch, only to settle on a re-run of a show you've both already seen. It’s comfortable, sure, but it’s not exactly bringing you closer together. What if your next couples' night in could spark genuine conversation, reveal new sides of your partner, and deepen your connection in a way a movie just can't?
Welcome to the world of the two-person book club. It's simpler than you think: you and your partner read the same book and then set aside an evening to talk about it—really talk. Not just about work schedules or who's taking out the bins, but about big ideas, moral dilemmas, and complex characters. I've always believed, much like a sentiment I once read from Goh Ling Yong, that shared intellectual and emotional journeys are the bedrock of a lasting connection. A book club for two is the perfect, low-pressure way to create those journeys.
But here’s the secret: you have to pick the right book. You don't want something that one person loves and the other snoozes through. You need a book with teeth—one that has layers, ambiguity, and characters whose choices are far from black and white. You need a book that makes you both put it down and say, "Okay, we need to talk about this." Below are eight fantastic, debate-sparking book club picks perfect for your next couples' night in.
1. Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn
This is the undisputed heavyweight champion of debate-sparking thrillers. On the morning of their fifth wedding anniversary, Nick Dunne's wife, Amy, disappears. As the police investigation and media frenzy intensify, the facade of their perfect marriage begins to crumble, revealing a twisted, dark reality underneath. Told from the alternating perspectives of Nick and Amy (through her diary), the story is a masterclass in unreliable narration.
Gone Girl is the ultimate couples' read because it directly confronts the nature of marriage, identity, and the personas we present to the world versus who we truly are. You and your partner will find yourselves taking sides, changing your minds, and then questioning everything you thought you knew. It forces a conversation about secrets, perception, and the terrifying chasm that can sometimes exist between two people who share a bed.
Discussion Starters:
- Let's talk about Amy's famous "Cool Girl" monologue. How much of that pressure to perform is real in modern relationships? Have you ever felt it?
- At what point in the book did your allegiance shift, if at all? Was there a moment where you stopped rooting for one character and started sympathizing with the other?
- Is it possible for a relationship built on such a complex web of lies and manipulation to ever find a version of "happily ever after"?
2. Fates and Furies by Lauren Groff
If Gone Girl is about the deconstruction of a marriage, Fates and Furies is about the wildly different ways a marriage can be perceived from the inside. The book tells the story of a 24-year marriage between Lotto and Mathilde. The first half, "Fates," is from Lotto's perspective, painting a picture of a charmed life, epic love, and artistic success, all buoyed by his perfect, supportive wife. The second half, "Furies," flips the script entirely and tells the story from Mathilde's point of view, revealing the immense sacrifices, secrets, and calculated moves that truly powered their union.
This book is a must-read for any long-term couple. It’s a stunning exploration of the idea that no matter how close you are, you can never fully know another person's inner world. It will have you discussing the invisible labor in relationships, the stories we tell ourselves about our partners, and the definition of a "successful" partnership. It’s a complex, beautifully written novel that will stick with you long after you’ve finished debating it.
Discussion Starters:
- Whose version of the marriage felt more "true" to you? Or are they both equally valid?
- Is what Mathilde did an act of profound love or profound deception? Can it be both?
- The book suggests that some degree of secrecy or illusion is necessary for a happy marriage. Do you agree or disagree?
3. Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro
For a different flavor of debate, step into the gentle, observant world of Klara, an "Artificial Friend" (AF) waiting in a store to be chosen by a child. Klara is exceptionally perceptive, and through her eyes, we see a near-future world grappling with genetic editing, loneliness, and what it truly means to love. When she is chosen by a sickly girl named Josie, Klara's purpose becomes to understand and save her human companion, leading to a profound exploration of faith, sacrifice, and the nature of consciousness.
Don't let the sci-fi premise fool you; this book is all heart. It's a quiet, philosophical novel that poses huge questions. For couples, it opens up conversations about the nature of unconditional love, what makes a person uniquely them, and whether a soul is something that can be replicated. It’s a less confrontational but incredibly deep and moving choice for a book club night.
Discussion Starters:
- Does Klara's love for Josie count as "real" love? What defines love, and is it exclusively a human emotion?
- The book explores the idea of whether there's an "unrepeatable" part of a person. What do you think that part is?
- Let's discuss the final scene. Was Klara's fate tragic or peaceful? Did she fulfill her purpose?
4. Little Fires Everywhere by Celeste Ng
Set in the meticulously planned suburb of Shaker Heights, Ohio, this novel explores the collision of two families: the wealthy, rule-following Richardsons and the enigmatic, artistic mother-daughter duo, Mia and Pearl Warren. When a local custody battle over a Chinese-American baby divides the town, everyone is forced to take a side, and the buried secrets of both families come dangerously to the surface.
This is the perfect book for couples who love to dissect social dynamics and moral gray areas. Celeste Ng is a master of showing how good intentions can lead to disastrous outcomes. The novel is a rich tapestry of themes—motherhood, class, secrets, identity, and the illusion of perfection. You and your partner will likely find yourselves on opposite sides of the book's central conflict, providing fertile ground for a fantastic discussion.
Discussion Starters:
- Who did you feel was more entitled to the baby: Bebe Chow or the McCulloughs? What factors influenced your decision?
- Is Elena Richardson a villain or simply a product of her privileged, structured environment?
- The book questions what makes someone a mother—biology, love, or providing a "good" life. What's your take?
5. The Midnight Library by Matt Haig
Between life and death, there is a library. In it, the shelves go on forever, and every book provides a chance to try another life you could have lived. Nora Seed, deeply unhappy with her life, finds herself in the Midnight Library with the chance to undo her regrets. She can see what would have happened if she'd made different choices—stayed with her ex, pursued her Olympic swimming dreams, or moved to Australia with her best friend.
This is a profoundly comforting yet thought-provoking read that will inevitably lead to a conversation about your own lives together. It's a great vehicle for discussing past regrets, pivotal choices, and what truly constitutes a fulfilling life. For couples, it can be a beautiful way to affirm the choices that led you to each other and to talk about your shared and individual dreams for the future.
Discussion Starters:
- If you could visit the Midnight Library, what is one "regret" you'd be tempted to undo, and why?
- Nora discovers that the "perfect" lives she imagined often came with their own unforeseen problems. How does this relate to the way we often idealize other people's lives on social media?
- What do you think is the book's ultimate message about happiness? Is it about finding the perfect life, or finding the good in the life you have?
6. Anxious People by Fredrik Backman
A failed bank robber stumbles into an apartment viewing and accidentally takes a group of strangers hostage. The group includes a wealthy bank director, two bickering real estate addicts, a pregnant woman, a young couple, and an old lady who isn't afraid of anyone. What follows is not a tense thriller, but a hilarious, compassionate, and deeply moving story about the messy, beautiful, and often hidden struggles of being human.
While not a "debate" book in the confrontational sense, Anxious People is a catalyst for deep, empathetic conversation. Backman has an incredible talent for revealing the profound pain and love that people hide behind their quirks and annoyances. It's a wonderful book for couples because it's a powerful reminder that everyone is fighting a battle you know nothing about—and that compassion and connection are the antidote. It's about how we save each other in small, everyday ways.
Discussion Starters:
- Which character did you relate to the most, and why? Was it who you expected?
- The story is about how strangers can impact each other's lives in profound ways. Can you think of a time a stranger had a surprising impact on you?
- Backman calls this a story about "idiots." What do you think he means by that, and how does that theme play out in the novel?
7. Where the Crawdads Sing by Delia Owens
For years, rumors have haunted Barkley Cove about the "Marsh Girl," Kya Clark, who has survived alone in the North Carolina marshes. When a popular local man is found dead, the town immediately suspects her. Part coming-of-age story, part murder mystery, and part ode to the natural world, this book is a phenomenon for a reason.
This is a great pick for couples who enjoy a gripping plot but also want something with substance to discuss. The novel explores themes of prejudice, loneliness, survival, and the profound connection between humans and nature. The mystery will keep you guessing, but the real discussions will stem from Kya’s character and the way society treats those who are different. The ending is also guaranteed to spark a major debate.
Discussion Starters:
- Is Kya a product of nature or nurture? How did her isolation in the marsh shape who she became?
- Discuss the theme of prejudice in the book. How did the town's judgment affect Kya's life and the outcome of the trial?
- Okay, let's talk about the ending (no spoilers here!). Were you surprised? Did it change your perception of Kya? Was justice served?
8. Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir
Looking for something completely different? Try this brilliant sci-fi novel from the author of The Martian. Ryland Grace wakes up on a spaceship with no memory of who he is or how he got there. His mission: save the Earth from an extinction-level event. Alone. Until he discovers he's not alone after all. What follows is a thrilling story of science, problem-solving, and an unlikely friendship.
This might seem like an odd choice for a couples' book club, but trust me. At its core, this book is about partnership, communication, and trust under extreme pressure. Watching Ryland and his unexpected partner work together to solve impossible problems is a fantastic, non-direct way to talk about how you and your partner function as a team. It’s fun, incredibly smart, and surprisingly emotional. It's a perfect palate cleanser from heavier literary fiction. As my friend Goh Ling Yong might say, sometimes the most profound insights about relationships come from the most unexpected places.
Discussion Starters:
- What makes the partnership between Grace and Rocky so effective, despite their inability to speak the same language initially?
- The book is filled with incredible moments of scientific problem-solving. Which one did you find most impressive or exciting?
- Discuss Grace's final choice. Would you have made the same one? Why or why not?
Starting a book club for two isn't about adding another "to-do" to your list. It's about carving out intentional time to connect on a deeper level. It’s about putting your phones away, pouring a glass of wine or a cup of tea, and exploring a new world together. The conversations that come from it can be surprising, insightful, and incredibly bonding.
So, ditch the endless scrolling. Pick one of these books, set a date, and get ready for a couples' night in that you'll actually be talking about for weeks to come.
Which book on this list sparks your interest the most? Or do you have another go-to, debate-sparking book you'd recommend for couples? Share your thoughts in the comments below
About the Author
Goh Ling Yong is a content creator and digital strategist sharing insights across various topics. Connect and follow for more content:
Stay updated with the latest posts and insights by following on your favorite platform!