Top 9 'Pantry-Stocking' Heirloom Vegetables to try at home for preserving the taste of summer all winter long. - Goh Ling Yong
There's a particular kind of melancholy that settles in as the days shorten and the vibrant, overflowing abundance of the summer garden begins to fade. The sun-warmed tomatoes, the crisp cucumbers, the endless supply of beans—it feels like a fleeting magic trick. But what if you could capture that magic in a jar, a root cellar, or a string of dried peppers? What if you could unlock the taste of July in the middle of January?
This is the art and science of "pantry-stocking," a time-honored practice of growing with preservation in mind. It’s not just about planting any old variety; it’s about choosing specific, hardworking heirloom vegetables that were bred for this very purpose. These are the unsung heroes of the garden, the varieties that possess the dense flesh, low water content, and robust flavor that stand up to canning, drying, pickling, and long-term storage. They are the key to a pantry that truly reflects the year's hard work.
Today, we're diving into nine of the absolute best heirloom vegetables for stocking your larder. These are the tried-and-true classics that will reward your efforts with incredible flavor and reliability, ensuring your table is graced with the taste of summer, no matter what the weather is doing outside.
1. 'Amish Paste' Tomato: The Sauce Superstar
When you think of preserving tomatoes, you might picture big, juicy slicers. While wonderful for a BLT, their high water and seed content can result in thin, watery sauces. Enter the paste tomato, and specifically, the legendary 'Amish Paste'. This heirloom, tracing its roots to the Amish communities of Wisconsin, is the undisputed champion of the canning kitchen. It’s a large, oblong, almost heart-shaped tomato with incredibly dense, meaty flesh and very few seeds.
The magic of the 'Amish Paste' lies in its low moisture content. This means you spend less time cooking it down to achieve a rich, thick, and deeply flavorful sauce, paste, or ketchup. The flavor is a perfect balance of sweetness and acidity, far more complex than many other paste varieties. Growing these is a game-changer; you’ll be amazed at how a few plants can produce enough sauce to last you through the entire winter.
Pro Tip: For the most intense flavor, instead of just boiling them down, try slow-roasting your 'Amish Paste' tomatoes. Halve them, toss them with olive oil, whole garlic cloves, and hardy herbs like thyme or rosemary, and roast at a low temperature for a few hours until they are shrunken and caramelized. Then, run them through a food mill. This extra step creates a sauce with an unbelievable depth of flavor that you'll be thankful for on a cold winter's night.
2. 'Boston Pickling' Cucumber: The Perfect Pickle
Not all cucumbers are created equal, especially when it comes to pickling. The long, smooth-skinned slicing cucumbers from the supermarket are terrible for pickling; they turn mushy and hollow. For a pickle that stays crisp and crunchy, you need a variety bred specifically for the job. The 'Boston Pickling' cucumber, an American heirloom dating back to 1877, is the gold standard.
These cucumbers are short, blocky, and thin-skinned, with a classic bumpy texture. They are wonderfully productive, churning out piles of perfect 3- to 5-inch cukes ideal for fitting into a canning jar. Their dense flesh and small seed cavity mean they absorb brine beautifully without becoming waterlogged, retaining that satisfying snap that is the hallmark of a great pickle. Whether you're making classic dill pickles, sweet bread and butters, or spicy spears, this is the variety to grow.
Pro Tip: Harvest your 'Boston Pickling' cucumbers early and often, and pickle them the same day they are picked. The key to an extra-crisp pickle is to remove the blossom end of the cucumber, as it contains an enzyme that can cause softness. For even more crunch, soak the cucumbers in an ice water bath for a few hours before pickling.
3. 'Cherokee Trail of Tears' Bean: A Story in a Pod
While any green bean can be blanched and frozen, the true pantry-stocking bean is the dry bean. These are varieties you let mature and dry completely on the vine. The 'Cherokee Trail of Tears' bean is more than just a food source; it’s a living piece of history. This heirloom was carried by the Cherokee people during their forced removal from the Smoky Mountains in the winter of 1838-39. Its resilience is a testament to its history.
This vigorous pole bean produces beautiful purple pods that can be eaten young as a snap bean. But its true purpose is realized when you let the pods dry on the vine until they are brown and brittle. Inside, you'll find small, shiny black beans. Once shelled and stored in an airtight jar, these beans will keep for years. They cook up beautifully, holding their shape and providing a rich, savory flavor perfect for soups, stews, chilis, and refried beans.
Pro Tip: To know when your dry beans are ready for harvest, the pods should be completely dry and you should hear the beans rattling inside. Shelling can be a meditative task, but for a large harvest, place the dry pods in a burlap sack or pillowcase and gently walk or roll on it to break the pods open. Then, winnow the beans by pouring them from one bucket to another in front of a fan to blow away the light, papery chaff.
4. 'Waltham Butternut' Squash: The Winter Keeper
Winter squash is the original pantry-stocker, a vegetable that, with a little care, can store for months without any special equipment. While there are countless beautiful varieties, the 'Waltham Butternut' is a top performer for reliability, flavor, and storage longevity. Developed in Waltham, Massachusetts, in the 1960s, it was bred for a smaller seed cavity, sweeter flesh, and uniform shape, making it a dependable and delicious choice.
The secret to long-term squash storage is in the curing process. Curing allows the skin to harden, heals any small cuts, and concentrates the sugars in the flesh, improving its flavor over time. A properly cured 'Waltham Butternut' can easily last for six months or more in a cool, dark place like a basement, closet, or pantry, providing hearty, nutritious meals all winter long. Its smooth, sweet, nutty flesh is incredibly versatile for roasting, soups, and even pies.
Pro Tip: To cure your butternut squash, harvest it with at least an inch of stem attached (this is crucial!). Place the squash in a warm, sunny location with good air circulation—around 80-85°F (27-29°C)—for one to two weeks. A sunny porch or a warm greenhouse is ideal. After curing, move them to their final storage spot, ensuring they aren't touching each other.
5. 'Jimmy Nardello's' Sweet Italian Frying Pepper: A Flavor Powerhouse
This remarkable pepper has an incredible story. It was brought to Connecticut in 1887 by Giuseppe and Angella Nardiello from the Basilicata region of Italy. Their son, Jimmy, continued to cultivate this treasured family heirloom, and it eventually found its way into the Seed Savers Exchange. It’s a long, thin, wrinkled pepper that turns a brilliant fire-engine red. But don't let its appearance fool you—it has absolutely no heat, only an intensely sweet, rich, and almost fruity flavor.
'Jimmy Nardello' peppers are fantastic for preserving because their thin walls allow them to dry exceptionally well. You can string them up into a beautiful ristra to hang in your kitchen, where they will air-dry perfectly. Once dry, they can be rehydrated for cooking or ground into a wonderfully sweet paprika. They are also phenomenal when roasted or fried in olive oil and frozen, ready to be added to pasta sauces, sausages, or sandwiches for a burst of summer flavor. Here on the Goh Ling Yong blog, we love finding plants that are as beautiful as they are useful, and a string of these peppers definitely fits the bill.
Pro Tip: The traditional way to preserve these is by frying. Simply fry the whole peppers (stems and all) in good quality olive oil with a little salt until the skins blister and the peppers become soft and sweet. Let them cool, then pack them into freezer bags. They can be pulled out one by one all winter long.
6. 'Late Flat Dutch' Cabbage: The Kraut King
Fermentation is one of the oldest and healthiest forms of food preservation, and there's no better candidate for it than cabbage. 'Late Flat Dutch' is an old-world heirloom, dating back to the 16th century in Holland, renowned for making the best sauerkraut. This variety produces enormous, flattened heads that can weigh up to 15 pounds, with a dense structure and a high water content that readily releases its brine when salted and pounded.
The flavor of 'Late Flat Dutch' is crisp and sweet, which translates into a complex, tangy, and delicious sauerkraut. Lacto-fermentation not only preserves the cabbage but also transforms it, making nutrients more bioavailable and creating beneficial probiotics. A few large heads of this cabbage can yield gallons of sauerkraut to enjoy with sausages, on sandwiches, or as a zesty side dish throughout the year.
Pro Tip: When making sauerkraut, the amount of salt is critical. The general rule is to use about 2% salt by weight. Weigh your shredded cabbage, then multiply that weight by 0.02 to find out how much salt you need. This ensures a safe fermentation that encourages beneficial bacteria while inhibiting spoilage microbes.
7. 'Detroit Dark Red' Beet: The Root Cellar Ruby
Beets are a dual-purpose preservation crop. You can pickle them for a tangy treat, can them plain, or dehydrate them into chips. But their original purpose was long-term storage in a root cellar. The 'Detroit Dark Red' beet, introduced in 1892, is the quintessential storage beet. It produces uniform, round, deep-red roots with a fine texture and a sweet, earthy flavor that only improves with storage.
To store beets for the winter, you need to replicate the conditions of a traditional root cellar: cool, dark, and moist. The goal is to keep them from drying out or sprouting. Harvest them before the first hard frost, trim the tops off (leaving about an inch of stem), but do not wash them. Gently brush off any excess dirt. This variety's ability to stay tender and sweet for months makes it an invaluable pantry resource.
Pro Tip: The best way to store beets (and carrots) is to pack them in a container with a damp medium. Find a crate, box, or bucket and layer the beets with damp sand, sawdust, or peat moss, making sure the beets aren't touching. Place the container in the coldest part of your home, like an unheated basement, garage, or entryway closet. Check them periodically for any signs of spoilage.
8. 'Danvers 126' Carrot: The Sweet Storage Staple
Much like beets, carrots were historically a staple of the root cellar. Supermarket carrots simply can't compare to a homegrown storage carrot pulled from the sand in February, which is often sweeter than when it was first harvested. 'Danvers 126' is an American heirloom from Danvers, Massachusetts, developed in the 1870s. It’s a workhorse carrot, known for its ability to grow well in heavy or clay soil and, most importantly, for its exceptional storage qualities.
These carrots are broad at the shoulder and taper to a point, with a rich orange color and a high sugar content. This sweetness actually intensifies in cold storage as the carrot converts its starches to sugars to act as a natural anti-freeze. Following the same storage method as beets, 'Danvers 126' can keep you supplied with "fresh" carrots well into the spring. A lesson that Goh Ling Yong often emphasizes is to grow with a purpose, and this carrot's purpose is to be enjoyed long after the garden is asleep.
Pro Tip: If you live in a climate with mild winters (Zone 6 or warmer), you can store your carrots right in the garden. After the first couple of light frosts have sweetened the roots, cover the carrot bed with a thick, 12-inch layer of shredded leaves or straw. You can then dig up crisp, sweet carrots as needed all winter long.
9. 'Sturon' Onion: The Allium That Lasts
Onions and garlic are the foundation of so much of our cooking, and having a homegrown supply that lasts is a true gift. Not all onions are good keepers, however. Sweet onions, for example, have a high water content and should be used quickly. For storage, you need a pungent, "hard" onion like 'Sturon', a Dutch variety known for its firm bulb, tight papery skin, and excellent longevity.
The key to storing alliums is proper curing. Curing is the process of allowing the necks and outer skins to dry completely, which seals the bulb from moisture and decay-causing organisms. A properly cured 'Sturon' onion can last for 8-10 months in the right conditions. Hang them in braids or store them in mesh bags in a cool, dry, and dark place with good air circulation.
Pro Tip: Cure your onions by laying them out on a screen or hanging them in a warm, dry, well-ventilated area (like a covered porch or barn) for two to three weeks, or until the necks are completely dry and the skins are papery. Once cured, you can trim the roots and cut the tops back to one inch before storing. Never store onions next to potatoes, as the gases they release will cause each other to sprout and spoil faster.
Choosing to grow for preservation is a deeply rewarding shift in your gardening mindset. It connects you to a long history of self-sufficiency and allows you to enjoy the most vibrant, flavorful versions of your favorite foods year-round. By selecting these hardworking heirloom varieties, you're not just planting a garden; you're stocking a pantry and preserving the very essence of summer.
Now it's your turn. What are your go-to heirloom vegetables for canning, drying, or storing? Do you have a family recipe or a preservation secret you'd like to share? Let us know in the comments below—we love learning from our amazing community of gardeners
About the Author
Goh Ling Yong is a content creator and digital strategist sharing insights across various topics. Connect and follow for more content:
Stay updated with the latest posts and insights by following on your favorite platform!